Max Drama
On October 29, 2018 at 6:20 AM, Lion Air Flight 610 took off from Jakarta, Indonesia
What do you think?
Rate your fear of flying on a 0-10 scale, with 10 meaning you’re terrified
See poll results only in the Roca app
Open in AppIndonesia-based Lion Air was flying Boeing’s 737 Max 8, the US aerospace manufacturer’s cutting-edge new plane, for a domestic flight
Immediately after takeoff, its pilots complained of “a flight control problem”
Twelve minutes later, the plane crashed into the Java Sea, killing all 189 passengers aboard
Five months later, an Ethiopian Airlines flight took off from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, for Nairobi, Kenya, also flying a 737 Max 8
Within a minute, pilots reported issues controlling the plane
Five minutes later, it crashed into the ground at 700+ miles per hour, killing all 157 passengers
Aviation experts cited a device known as a Maneuvering Control Augmentation System (MCAS) as a contributing factor in both crashes
Amid the ensuing backlash, every country grounded its Boeing 737 Max fleets, plunging Boeing into a crisis
Now, following a disastrous mid-flight accident over Oregon, the plane is back in the headlines
Boeing is the world’s largest commercial aerospace manufacturer by market cap
Its flagship class of planes is the 737, which, since its debut in 1967, has become the best-selling airplane class ever
In 2006, it began considering a new model to succeed its then-current version, the 737NG
Boeing debated whether to build a new version of the 737 or create a new class of planes
Then in December 2010, Boeing’s competitor, Airbus, announced its new class of planes
Worried Airbus would out-compete it, Boeing began building a new version of the 737: The Max
In August 2011, Boeing announced it would create three versions of the Max – the 7, 8, and 9 – which would differ based on their size and other performance metrics
Crucially, each Max version was designed to be very similar to the 737NG, meaning that pilots and aircrews wouldn’t have to go through comprehensive training to learn how to fly them
Yet structurally, the Max had notable differences from the NG, including stronger engines that were positioned at different positions of the plane
That created different aerodynamics, including the tendency for the plane’s nose to tilt upward
Yet rather than totally redesign the plane, Boeing installed MCAS, which automatically adjusted the plane’s nose to keep it stable
In theory, MCAS worked in the background, meaning the plane’s pilots would never notice it
MCAS was designed to respond to a single sensor
That meant that if one of its two sensors malfunctioned, the MCAS system could wrongfully kick in, taking control of the plane from the pilots
The pilots could manually override that system, but doing so presented its own difficulties
The Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines crashes showed that design flaw to be fatal: In both instances, MCAS incorrectly kicked in, leading to confusion, panic, and ultimately fatal crashes
Following the second crash, the world’s 737 Max-8 fleets were grounded, costing Boeing billions in lost revenue, lawsuits, and fines
Subsequent investigations revealed that an internal US federal report had predicted up to 15 Max crashes over a 30-40-year span – yet the US had let it fly
US regulators soon accused Boeing of having concealed crucial details about MCAS, resulting in information being absent from airplane manuals and pilot-training materials
The US said Boeing purposefully withheld that information to make the Max and its predecessor appear more similar than they actually were
That allowed airlines to use the same pilots for both NGs and 737s, saving them money and making the Max a more sellable plane
In 2021, Boeing paid $2.5B to settle related claims
The US approved the Max to fly again on November 18, 2020, almost two years after the second crash, and most other countries followed shortly after
The Max has since gone on to become Boeing’s best-selling model, and 76% of the company’s outstanding orders are for it
Yet another blow to Boeing came last week when a Max 9 flying from Oregon to California suffered a mid-flight blowout, exposing a gaping hole in its fuselage
No one was seriously injured, but the plane was brand new, raising concerns about inherent flaws in the Max
Several airlines have since attested to finding loose bolts on Max 9s
As another investigation begins, hundreds of 737 Maxs remain stuck on the ground once again
You can read more stories like this in our app
Roca makes staying informed actually fun. Read more stories, solidify your learning with quizzes, play minigames, earn XP, level up, and climb leaderboards