Open in App
a
Max Drama

Max Drama

  • On October 29, 2018 at 6:20 AM, Lion Air Flight 610 took off from Jakarta, Indonesia

What do you think?

Rate your fear of flying on a 0-10 scale, with 10 meaning you’re terrified

  • 0-2
  • 3-5
  • 6-8
  • 9+

See poll results only in the Roca app

Open in App
  • Indonesia-based Lion Air was flying Boeing’s 737 Max 8, the US aerospace manufacturer’s cutting-edge new plane, for a domestic flight

  • Immediately after takeoff, its pilots complained of “a flight control problem”

  • Twelve minutes later, the plane crashed into the Java Sea, killing all 189 passengers aboard

  • Five months later, an Ethiopian Airlines flight took off from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, for Nairobi, Kenya, also flying a 737 Max 8

  • Within a minute, pilots reported issues controlling the plane

  • Five minutes later, it crashed into the ground at 700+ miles per hour, killing all 157 passengers

  • Aviation experts cited a device known as a Maneuvering Control Augmentation System (MCAS) as a contributing factor in both crashes

  • Amid the ensuing backlash, every country grounded its Boeing 737 Max fleets, plunging Boeing into a crisis

  • Now, following a disastrous mid-flight accident over Oregon, the plane is back in the headlines

  • Boeing is the world’s largest commercial aerospace manufacturer by market cap

  • Its flagship class of planes is the 737, which, since its debut in 1967, has become the best-selling airplane class ever

  • In 2006, it began considering a new model to succeed its then-current version, the 737NG

  • Boeing debated whether to build a new version of the 737 or create a new class of planes

  • Then in December 2010, Boeing’s competitor, Airbus, announced its new class of planes

  • Worried Airbus would out-compete it, Boeing began building a new version of the 737: The Max

  • In August 2011, Boeing announced it would create three versions of the Max – the 7, 8, and 9 – which would differ based on their size and other performance metrics

  • Crucially, each Max version was designed to be very similar to the 737NG, meaning that pilots and aircrews wouldn’t have to go through comprehensive training to learn how to fly them

  • Yet structurally, the Max had notable differences from the NG, including stronger engines that were positioned at different positions of the plane

  • That created different aerodynamics, including the tendency for the plane’s nose to tilt upward

  • Yet rather than totally redesign the plane, Boeing installed MCAS, which automatically adjusted the plane’s nose to keep it stable

  • In theory, MCAS worked in the background, meaning the plane’s pilots would never notice it

  • MCAS was designed to respond to a single sensor

  • That meant that if one of its two sensors malfunctioned, the MCAS system could wrongfully kick in, taking control of the plane from the pilots

  • The pilots could manually override that system, but doing so presented its own difficulties

  • The Lion Air and Ethiopian Airlines crashes showed that design flaw to be fatal: In both instances, MCAS incorrectly kicked in, leading to confusion, panic, and ultimately fatal crashes

  • Following the second crash, the world’s 737 Max-8 fleets were grounded, costing Boeing billions in lost revenue, lawsuits, and fines

  • Subsequent investigations revealed that an internal US federal report had predicted up to 15 Max crashes over a 30-40-year span – yet the US had let it fly

  • US regulators soon accused Boeing of having concealed crucial details about MCAS, resulting in information being absent from airplane manuals and pilot-training materials

  • The US said Boeing purposefully withheld that information to make the Max and its predecessor appear more similar than they actually were

  • That allowed airlines to use the same pilots for both NGs and 737s, saving them money and making the Max a more sellable plane

  • In 2021, Boeing paid $2.5B to settle related claims

  • The US approved the Max to fly again on November 18, 2020, almost two years after the second crash, and most other countries followed shortly after

  • The Max has since gone on to become Boeing’s best-selling model, and 76% of the company’s outstanding orders are for it

  • Yet another blow to Boeing came last week when a Max 9 flying from Oregon to California suffered a mid-flight blowout, exposing a gaping hole in its fuselage

  • No one was seriously injured, but the plane was brand new, raising concerns about inherent flaws in the Max

  • Several airlines have since attested to finding loose bolts on Max 9s

  • As another investigation begins, hundreds of 737 Maxs remain stuck on the ground once again

  • You can read more stories like this in our app

  • Roca makes staying informed actually fun. Read more stories, solidify your learning with quizzes, play minigames, earn XP, level up, and climb leaderboards